Thursday, August 09, 2007

Easy steps to better legalism

Check out these insights from the I-wish-I-could-have-said-it-that-well-myself department:
I have for a while believed that the generic Osteenish faith of popular Christianity is really just legalism warmed over. That seems counterintuitive, because the smiling face that self-help "Christianity" puts on evangelicalism claims to be setting followers free from rules and judgmental religion. But really, by making discipleship about helpful hints and positive power for successful living, it's really just making a works religion in our new image. In an odd twist, the Oprah-ization of the faith is really just optimistic legalism. Because what is Pharisaical legalism, really, but self-help with bad p.r.?

And people love this stuff. They want to be told religion is not about rules and regulations while at the same time being told each week which four steps (with helpful alliteration) they need to do in order to achieve maximum what-have-you. They want to be reassured that works don't merit salvation while at the same time convinced salvation is about trying really hard to do things that unlock the power or secret of God's such-and-such. (And I've never seen what is such Good News about following a list of instructions in order to button-push God into granting me His favor.)
That's Jared Wilson, and he's really hit a long ball with that one. Thanks to Promises Kept for the link.

4 Comments:

Blogger Matt said...

"They want to be reassured that works don't merit salvation while at the same time convinced salvation is about trying really hard to do things that unlock the power or secret of God's such-and-such."

Sounds like magic to me. I do this and then this and then this in that order and poof. God loves me!

12:16 PM, August 09, 2007  
Blogger Milton Stanley said...

Bingo.

1:30 PM, August 09, 2007  
Blogger Brian Littlefield said...

Actually, I'm not sure that the differentiation is that clean-cut. I've had friends that attend Lakewood Church, and it never seems like they're constantly struggling with believing they're saved (that's a completely different debate), or whether God loves them. It's more akin to whether God likes them, and likes them enough to send more material blessings their way. In that respect, it is like magic (or alchemy, rather), because they're always looking for a way of doing things or looking at things that will give them the maximum benefit. The goal of their worship is to get the most (toys) in life. It's very self-centered, really.

9:14 AM, August 12, 2007  
Blogger Milton Stanley said...

Good points, Brian. Your comments show the deficiencies of the health & wealth message from another angle.

8:03 AM, August 13, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home